Home Saloons CarsThat Last
EN
Reliability ranking

The most reliable saloons

77 saloons ranked on 2,517,847 inspections in the Netherlands and the UK · updated 13 November 2026

Saloons differ a lot. The best scores 9.7 out of 10 and the worst 5.3. A typical one scores 7.4.

If reliability matters most, the Lexus IS300H, Lexus GS and Lexus ES300H are the safest bets.

Our top three

Most reliable
9.7likely 9.3 to 9.9

Lexus IS300H

Technical faults turn up 72% less often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. Based on 14,484 cars registered 2013 to 2020.

Is the Lexus IS300H reliable?
2
Runner-up

Lexus GS

9.7

Technical faults turn up 70% less often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. Based on 3,078 cars registered 2012 to 2018.

Is the Lexus GS reliable?
3
Third place

Lexus ES300H

9.5

Technical faults turn up 64% less often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. Based on 4,362 cars registered 2019 to 2022.

Is the Lexus ES300H reliable?

The full ranking

Every saloon with at least 1,000 cars inspected. Tap a car for its likely range, its years and the fault to watch for.

1Lexus IS300HBetter than most saloons14,484 cars9.7
Likely 9.3 to 9.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Hybrid · registered 2013 to 2020
9.720139.820149.820159.620169.420179.820189.920199.82020
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Lexus IS300H reliable?
2Lexus GSBetter than most saloons3,078 cars9.7
Likely 9.0 to 9.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid · registered 2012 to 2018
9.720129.920139.020149.920159.8201610.02017
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Lexus GS reliable?
3Lexus ES300HBetter than most saloons4,362 cars9.5
Likely 8.3 to 9.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Hybrid · registered 2019 to 2022
9.720199.620209.020219.52022
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Lexus ES300H reliable?
4Porsche PanameraBetter than most saloons9,645 cars9.4
Likely 8.9 to 9.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2009 to 2022
9.520109.420119.620129.120139.420148.720159.520179.720189.720199.620207.920218.82022
Watch for: Engine warning light: on or not working, found 67% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Porsche Panamera reliable?
5BMW I4Better than most saloons8,278 cars9.2
Likely 7.5 to 9.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Electric · registered 2022 to 2023
9.22022
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the BMW I4 reliable?
6BMW AlpinaBetter than most saloons1,553 cars9.2
Likely 8.3 to 9.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2007 to 2007
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the BMW Alpina reliable?
7Audi A8Better than most saloons11,641 cars9.1
Likely 8.6 to 9.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2003 to 2022
8.620079.420088.820109.520119.420129.620139.620149.720159.320169.420179.420189.62019
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Audi A8 reliable?
8Lexus GS450HBetter than most saloons1,548 cars9.1
Likely 7.9 to 9.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Hybrid · registered 2006 to 2012
8.92007
Watch for: Shock absorber: serious fluid leak, found 38% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Lexus GS450H reliable?
9Lexus IS250Better than most saloons10,833 cars9.1
Likely 8.5 to 9.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 2005 to 2013
8.920058.620069.220079.320089.220099.520109.420119.72012
Watch for: Stability control (ESC): warning light shows a fault, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Lexus IS250 reliable?
10Porsche TaycanProbably better than most saloons12,256 cars8.9
Likely 7.0 to 9.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Electric · registered 2020 to 2023
8.420209.120219.22022
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Porsche Taycan reliable?
11Audi A7Better than most saloons17,638 cars8.9
Likely 8.3 to 9.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2011 to 2022
8.520119.220129.120139.220149.020158.420168.920179.320188.620199.020206.820217.32022
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 48% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Audi A7 reliable?
12Bentley ArnageBetter than most saloons1,332 cars8.8
Likely 7.5 to 9.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1999 to 2005
Watch for: Airbag warning light: shows a fault, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Bentley Arnage reliable?
13Maserati QuattroporteBetter than most saloons1,748 cars8.8
Likely 7.7 to 9.4Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2007 to 2008
Watch for: Handbrake: too weak, found 89% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Maserati Quattroporte reliable?
14Rolls-Royce SilverBetter than most saloons1,393 cars8.7
Likely 7.4 to 9.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol
Watch for: Handbrake: under half the required strength, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Rolls-Royce Silver reliable?
15Maserati GhibliBetter than most saloons3,572 cars8.6
Likely 7.5 to 9.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2014 to 2021
9.520148.720158.020168.720177.72018
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Maserati Ghibli reliable?
16Toyota CamryProbably better than most saloons2,316 cars8.6
Likely 7.3 to 9.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid · registered 2002 to 2021
9.820199.82020
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Toyota Camry reliable?
17Lexus IS220Better than most saloons3,411 cars8.5
Likely 7.5 to 9.2Yellow line: typical saloon
Diesel · registered 2006 to 2010
8.720068.720079.020088.120098.22010
Watch for: Footbrake: uneven as the wheel turns, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Lexus IS220 reliable?
18Mercedes-Benz 500Probably better than most saloons1,239 cars8.5
Likely 6.9 to 9.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1989 to 1991
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Mercedes-Benz 500 reliable?
19Lexus GS300Probably better than most saloons2,596 cars8.4
Likely 7.3 to 9.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 2003 to 2008
8.620058.32006
Watch for: Stability control (ESC): warning light shows a fault, found 11× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Lexus GS300 reliable?
20Audi A5Better than most saloons134,891 cars8.2
Likely 7.4 to 8.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2007 to 2022
8.420118.520128.720138.620149.120158.720167.420178.220188.220197.920207.620218.42022
Watch for: Coil spring: broken, found 63% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Audi A5 reliable?
21Kia StingerProbably better than most saloons2,125 cars8.2
Likely 6.4 to 9.2Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2017 to 2022
8.620187.62019
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Kia Stinger reliable?
22Alfa Romeo GiuliaProbably better than most saloons9,554 cars8.1
Likely 7.0 to 8.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2016 to 2022
8.620178.420186.220195.720207.720219.32022
Watch for: Emission control system incomplete, found 18× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Alfa Romeo Giulia reliable?
23Mercedes-Benz S-ClassProbably better than most saloons28,171 cars8.1
Likely 7.2 to 8.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 1997 to 2022
7.720117.420128.220138.920148.720158.120167.520178.320189.820199.220208.820219.92022
Watch for: Ball joint excessive play, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Mercedes-Benz S-Class reliable?
24BMW 7 SeriesProbably better than most saloons20,082 cars8.0
Likely 7.1 to 8.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 1996 to 2022
8.520118.820128.020139.020148.420158.720168.820178.820189.320199.820209.420219.82022
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the BMW 7 Series reliable?
25Mercedes-Benz 300Probably better than most saloons2,508 cars8.0
Likely 6.5 to 9.0Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1986 to 1993
7.919888.51989
Watch for: Exhaust emissions: carbon monoxide too high, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Mercedes-Benz 300 reliable?
26Jaguar XJRProbably better than most saloons2,051 cars7.9
Likely 6.6 to 8.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1998 to 2007
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint dust cover: lets dirt in, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Jaguar XJR reliable?
27Jaguar XEProbably better than most saloons41,776 cars7.9
Likely 6.8 to 8.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2015 to 2021
8.020158.120168.220177.820186.020195.720204.02021
Watch for: Shock absorber: serious fluid leak, found 62% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Jaguar XE reliable?
28Jaguar XFProbably better than most saloons90,446 cars7.9
Likely 7.0 to 8.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2008 to 2021
7.820107.620117.520127.720137.820148.720158.820168.820178.120187.520197.620208.32021
Watch for: Ball joint boot damaged, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Jaguar XF reliable?
29Volkswagen ArteonProbably better than most saloons11,717 cars7.9
Likely 6.6 to 8.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2017 to 2022
9.120178.520188.920197.620205.320217.52022
Watch for: Brake disc badly corroded, found 7× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volkswagen Arteon reliable?
30BMW 5 SeriesProbably better than most saloons232,451 cars7.9
Likely 7.0 to 8.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 1986 to 2023
8.220118.220128.420138.420148.720158.820168.220178.820188.820198.820209.420219.72022
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the BMW 5 Series reliable?
31Volvo S80Probably better than most saloons10,234 cars7.9
Likely 6.9 to 8.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2016
7.520047.520057.820068.320078.320088.720098.420107.720118.120128.720138.920147.82015
Watch for: Driveshaft boot damaged, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volvo S80 reliable?
32Mercedes-Benz 280About average for a saloon1,313 cars7.8
Likely 5.8 to 9.0Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1985 to 1985
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Mercedes-Benz 280 reliable?
33Lexus IS200About average for a saloon5,395 cars7.8
Likely 6.6 to 8.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2011
6.620007.920017.420027.720038.220047.720059.12011
Watch for: Suspension mounting area: excessively corroded, found 60% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Lexus IS200 reliable?
34Mercedes-Benz 230About average for a saloon1,215 cars7.6
Likely 5.6 to 8.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Mercedes-Benz 230 reliable?
35Jaguar XJAbout average for a saloon22,486 cars7.6
Likely 6.5 to 8.4Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1993 to 2020
8.120087.620098.220108.020118.720127.920138.020148.520157.920168.520179.120189.62019
Watch for: Ball joint boot damaged, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Jaguar XJ reliable?
36Tesla Model SAbout average for a saloon16,588 cars7.6
Likely 4.9 to 9.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Electric · registered 2013 to 2020
8.320137.520148.020157.520167.220177.920187.120194.32020
Watch for: Track rod end excessive play, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Tesla Model S reliable?
37BMW 3 SeriesAbout average for a saloon537,404 cars7.5
Likely 6.5 to 8.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel, LPG · registered 1986 to 2023
8.120128.520138.820149.020159.020169.020179.120189.220198.520208.020218.320227.52023
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 91% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the BMW 3 Series reliable?
38Mercedes-Benz EQSAbout average for a saloon1,017 cars7.5
Likely 3.9 to 9.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Electric · registered 2022 to 2022
8.12022
Nothing stands out among technical faults.
Is the Mercedes-Benz EQS reliable?
39Honda AccordAbout average for a saloon23,989 cars7.3
Likely 6.2 to 8.2Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1998 to 2015
6.920037.020047.320057.520067.320078.320087.920098.220108.720118.620128.720138.12014
Watch for: ABS warning light on, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Honda Accord reliable?
40Mercedes-Benz E-ClassAbout average for a saloon239,492 cars7.3
Likely 6.3 to 8.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 1993 to 2022
7.120116.520126.720136.820146.920157.920167.820178.220188.420199.120209.420219.22022
Watch for: Ball joint excessive play, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Mercedes-Benz E-Class reliable?
41Mercedes-Benz CLSAbout average for a saloon23,322 cars7.3
Likely 6.2 to 8.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2005 to 2021
7.720086.920096.920108.320118.520127.520137.120147.320157.320166.820176.720186.92019
Watch for: Ball joint excessive play, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Mercedes-Benz CLS reliable?
42Mercedes-Benz CLAAbout average for a saloon90,587 cars7.2
Likely 6.0 to 8.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2013 to 2023
7.920137.520146.920156.720167.420178.120186.520196.320206.820216.82022
Watch for: Coil spring: broken, found 77% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Mercedes-Benz CLA reliable?
43Volvo S60About average for a saloon29,061 cars7.1
Likely 6.0 to 8.0Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel, LPG · registered 2001 to 2022
8.120117.120128.020136.720148.320159.220166.420178.620186.720196.120208.320218.42022
Watch for: Driveshaft boot damaged, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volvo S60 reliable?
44Kia OptimaAbout average for a saloon11,122 cars7.1
Likely 5.7 to 8.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2012 to 2019
5.120126.520136.620146.920158.220167.720177.820186.52019
Watch for: Brake pads: less than 1.5 mm thick, found 60% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Kia Optima reliable?
45Saab 9-5About average for a saloon10,059 cars7.0
Likely 5.8 to 8.0Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel, LPG · registered 1999 to 2011
6.520007.420016.720026.520037.320046.720056.620067.320076.820087.120097.920108.62011
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 72% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Saab 9-5 reliable?
46Mercedes-Benz 190About average for a saloon2,397 cars7.0
Likely 5.2 to 8.3Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1988 to 1993
7.119907.019916.719927.21993
Watch for: Exhaust emissions: carbon monoxide too high, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Mercedes-Benz 190 reliable?
47Tesla Model 3About average for a saloon104,210 cars7.0
Likely 4.2 to 8.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Electric · registered 2019 to 2023
7.420196.920207.120218.12022
Watch for: Ball joint excessive play, found 87% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Tesla Model 3 reliable?
48Volvo S90About average for a saloon8,590 cars7.0
Likely 5.7 to 8.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2016 to 2022
5.220178.720188.420197.12020
Watch for: Ball joint boot damaged, found 6× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volvo S90 reliable?
49Mercedes-Benz C-ClassAbout average for a saloon398,475 cars7.0
Likely 5.9 to 7.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel, LPG · registered 1994 to 2023
6.620116.520126.620137.620147.320157.320167.420178.320188.720198.620209.220219.22022
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Mercedes-Benz C-Class reliable?
50Saab 9-3About average for a saloon45,937 cars7.0
Likely 5.8 to 7.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel, LPG · registered 1998 to 2012
6.220006.620017.420026.920036.920047.120057.120067.420077.420086.920096.720107.02011
Watch for: Particulate filter faulty (too many particles), found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Saab 9-3 reliable?
51Infiniti Q50About average for a saloon2,272 cars6.8
Likely 5.0 to 8.2Yellow line: typical saloon
Diesel · registered 2014 to 2018
6.620156.320164.42017
Watch for: Anti-roll bar link ball joint: excessively worn, found 6× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Infiniti Q50 reliable?
52Opel OmegaAbout average for a saloon1,119 cars6.8
Likely 5.3 to 8.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 2001 to 2003
Watch for: Suspension mounting area: excessively corroded, found 68% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Opel Omega reliable?
53Polestar 2About average for a saloon17,899 cars6.7
Likely 3.8 to 8.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Electric · registered 2020 to 2023
2.320208.520218.720229.92023
Watch for: Driveshaft boot damaged, found 9× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Polestar 2 reliable?
54Volkswagen CCProbably worse than most saloons13,085 cars6.6
Likely 5.4 to 7.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2011 to 2017
7.120126.520136.520146.120156.42016
Watch for: Suspension arm bushes: excessively worn, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Volkswagen CC reliable?
55Volvo S40Probably worse than most saloons20,187 cars6.4
Likely 5.2 to 7.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2012
5.320016.020025.420035.920046.520057.220067.320077.120087.420097.120105.520115.82012
Watch for: Spring broken or cracked, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volvo S40 reliable?
56Saab 900Probably worse than most saloons3,267 cars6.4
Likely 4.9 to 7.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1989 to 1997
6.019936.21997
Watch for: Handbrake: too weak, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Saab 900 reliable?
57MG ZTProbably worse than most saloons1,830 cars6.4
Likely 4.6 to 7.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2002 to 2005
5.620036.820046.32005
Watch for: Airbag warning light: shows a fault, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the MG ZT reliable?
58Volkswagen BoraProbably worse than most saloons5,747 cars6.4
Likely 5.1 to 7.4Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2006
5.120006.020016.820026.620036.620046.62005
Watch for: Drive shaft joint: CV boot split or insecure, found 74% more often than on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Volkswagen Bora reliable?
59Volvo S70Probably worse than most saloons1,050 cars6.3
Likely 4.7 to 7.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1997 to 2000
6.419975.81998
Watch for: ABS warning light on, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volvo S70 reliable?
60Mitsubishi LancerProbably worse than most saloons11,186 cars6.2
Likely 4.9 to 7.4Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1998 to 2015
8.720046.820056.920065.620075.720085.920095.720104.82011
Watch for: Track rod end excessive play, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Mitsubishi Lancer reliable?
61Jaguar Cars JaguarProbably worse than most saloons1,633 cars6.2
Likely 4.3 to 7.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 2000 to 2008
Watch for: Ball joint boot damaged, found 5× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Jaguar Cars Jaguar reliable?
62Peugeot 406Worse than most saloons3,338 cars6.1
Likely 4.8 to 7.2Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1998 to 2004
5.520006.520015.920026.22003
Watch for: Exhaust leaking / unsafe outlet, found 61% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 406 reliable?
63Jaguar S-TypeProbably worse than most saloons8,772 cars6.0
Likely 4.3 to 7.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2007
4.719993.720004.720015.420025.920036.220046.220057.020066.82007
Watch for: Suspension arm ball joint dust cover: lets dirt in, found 6× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Jaguar S-Type reliable?
64Chrysler 300CWorse than most saloons4,548 cars6.0
Likely 4.7 to 7.2Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2005 to 2013
6.020066.220075.820085.820095.52010
Watch for: Handbrake: under half the required strength, found 9× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Chrysler 300C reliable?
65Peugeot 508Worse than most saloons22,737 cars5.8
Likely 4.7 to 6.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2011 to 2022
6.320116.220125.820136.220145.620155.320165.320174.020184.520194.320204.920214.52022
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 508 reliable?
66Volvo 800Probably worse than most saloons1,458 cars5.8
Likely 3.8 to 7.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1994 to 1997
6.319955.51996
Watch for: Drive shaft joint: CV boot split or insecure, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in UK MOT tests.
Is the Volvo 800 reliable?
67Alfa Romeo 156Worse than most saloons1,604 cars5.7
Likely 4.2 to 7.1Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 2001 to 2004
6.52003
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Alfa Romeo 156 reliable?
68SEAT ExeoWorse than most saloons4,541 cars5.7
Likely 4.5 to 6.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2009 to 2013
6.220095.820105.520115.320125.52013
Watch for: Brake hose damaged, found 32× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the SEAT Exeo reliable?
69Jaguar X-TypeWorse than most saloons18,761 cars5.6
Likely 4.4 to 6.8Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2001 to 2010
4.220015.620025.320034.820045.920055.920065.820075.820085.92009
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 74% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Jaguar X-Type reliable?
70Nissan PrimeraWorse than most saloons3,386 cars5.6
Likely 4.2 to 6.9Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol · registered 1998 to 2006
5.920025.820045.320056.02006
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Nissan Primera reliable?
71Opel VectraWorse than most saloons25,670 cars5.6
Likely 4.3 to 6.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1998 to 2009
5.919995.720006.120015.520025.520035.420046.120055.920065.220075.320085.22009
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 83% more often than on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Opel Vectra reliable?
72SEAT ToledoWorse than most saloons6,569 cars5.5
Likely 4.2 to 6.7Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2003 to 2018
6.620136.720146.620157.020164.620173.92018
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the SEAT Toledo reliable?
73Volkswagen JettaWorse than most saloons15,289 cars5.4
Likely 4.2 to 6.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2006 to 2017
5.620066.120076.120086.220095.720105.120115.020124.520134.720144.220154.020163.42017
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Volkswagen Jetta reliable?
74Renault LagunaWorse than most saloons10,079 cars5.4
Likely 4.2 to 6.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2003 to 2012
5.120055.120064.620075.320085.720096.020105.12011
Watch for: Spring broken or cracked, found 4× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Renault Laguna reliable?
75Citroën C5Worse than most saloons25,418 cars5.4
Likely 4.1 to 6.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Hybrid, Diesel · registered 2002 to 2022
5.720065.620076.420085.920095.120104.520114.220124.720135.120194.720205.920215.12022
Watch for: Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.), found 2× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Citroën C5 reliable?
76Peugeot 407Worse than most saloons8,498 cars5.3
Likely 4.2 to 6.5Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 2004 to 2011
6.320045.420054.920065.220076.020085.920095.12010
Watch for: ABS warning light on, found 8× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Peugeot 407 reliable?
77Rover 75Worse than most saloons6,316 cars5.3
Likely 4.0 to 6.6Yellow line: typical saloon
Petrol, Diesel · registered 1999 to 2006
5.120015.420025.620035.220045.42005
Watch for: Airbag / seatbelt warning light on, found 3× as often as on comparable cars in Dutch inspections.
Is the Rover 75 reliable?

All fuel types together. Ranks and verdicts compare with every saloon.

Think twice

The three saloons with the lowest scores, and the fault that stands out on each.

Airbag / seatbelt warning light on: found on 18.4% of cars, 3 times the usual rate. 6,316 cars. Worse than most saloons.

ABS warning light on: found on 10.7% of cars, 8 times the usual rate. 8,498 cars. Worse than most saloons.

Excessive fluid leak (oil, coolant etc.): found on 18.2% of cars, 2 times the usual rate. 25,418 cars. Worse than most saloons.

How we rank

What the score measures

Each score comes from the cars' most recent inspections in the Netherlands and the UK. We count technical defects and compare with the average car of the same age and fuel. A score of 6.0 is average for any car. The typical saloon scores 7.4. A model is called better or worse than most only when the data makes that likely, and both countries count.